Medical experts in Shanxi to investigate vaccine problems


By Shan Juan
China Daily

BEIJING – A team of eight medical experts sent by the Chinese Medical Association has arrived in Shanxi province to help with the ongoing investigation of the latest vaccine scandal.

Specialists in neurology, allergic reaction, vaccine adverse reaction, immunization planning, as well as infectious and blood diseases were sent to Shanxi at the request of the provincial medical association to ensure the probe is scientific, transparent and accurate, Xinhua News Agency reported on Monday.

The Beijing-based China Economic Times reported on March 17 that improperly stored vaccines administered by the provincial Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) had killed four children and sickened more than 70 others who had been vaccinated between 2006 and 2008.

“What’s the point of the investigation given that it has been three years since the first adverse reactions allegedly caused by improper storage were first reported by families of the victims?” asked Cao Lingsheng, a division director of the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention’s immunization center.

“Vaccine samples taken then cannot provide valid test results, if there are any left for testing,” he told China Daily.

He added that it will be hard, if not impossible, to collect sound proof to link or unlink the victims’ deaths and illnesses to the vaccines.

Li Tiantian, a doctor at the Peking Union Medical College, agreed.

“It’s not right to simply relate the deaths and injuries of nearly 100 children to vaccines they had received years ago, or to the improper storage of the vaccines,” he noted.

Doctors find it hard to diagnose minor patients showing symptoms like twitching and fever, according to Li.

Children are usually sent to a hospital several days after showing the symptoms, making it hard for doctors to track the cause, let alone several years later, he said.

Besides, adverse reactions to vaccines, as scientific studies have found, tend to emerge shortly after the vaccination, he said.

The deaths mentioned in the report happened days or even months after immunization, said Li.

Most of the widely used type B encephalitis, hepatitis B and rabies vaccines in China contain dead microorganisms, which are safe and only become less effective if improperly stored, according to Cao.

However, he conceded that attenuated vaccines, which contain live microorganisms, might impact the recipient’s health, if not properly refrigerated.

Loopholes in the vaccine management system in Shanxi should be detected and corrected through the investigation, he said.

The provincial government on March 22 admitted the provincial CDC and the vaccine provider, the Beijing-based Huawei Shidai Company, had violated certain rules, but assured the vaccines were safe.

The local government launched a special investigation into the scandal the same day, assisted by an eight-member group sent by the Ministry of Health and joined by experts from other provinces.

The provincial food and drug administration launched an inspection campaign on vaccine quality and safety last week.

The province’s health authority ruled out any link between 15 children who died or fell ill and the vaccines provided by Huawei, according to a preliminary investigation result quoted in the Shanghai-based Oriental Morning Post last week.

However, the provincial authority has yet to confirm the report, as local officials and experts could not be reached for comment on Monday.

Mixed feelings about scandal

“The recent scandal makes me confused. I do not know who I should trust, the government or the media,” Qiao Fengzhi, the grandmother of 14-month-old Jian Jian, said while walking out of the Yingze district disease prevention and control station in downtown Taiyuan, the capital city of Shanxi province.

“We will not allow my grandson to be inoculated before the authority releases the final investigation result,” the 67-year-old said.

Fewer people came to receive vaccinations this week at the Taiyuan center for disease control and prevention (CDC) due to the ongoing scandal, said a doctor with the center’s vaccination injection unit.

Zhai Wei, a resident of neighboring Xinzhou city, said she could not make up her mind whether to proceed with vaccinations for her 8-month-old daughter, who has already been vaccinated for tuberculosis, hepatitis B, measles, epidemic cerebrospinal meningitis and polio, in addition to a triple shot for diphtheria, tetanus and pertussis.

“I don’t know what to do. To allow the baby to receive shots could protect her from possible diseases, but it could also risk her health as the safety of vaccines still has yet to be ensured,” she said.

The vaccine scandal also affected people in other parts of the country, with parents becoming hesitant about their children receiving shots in Guangzhou, Shenyang, Hefei, Hainan and Ningbo, local media reported.

The Ministry of Health, the nation’s top health authority, issued a handful of notices defending both the quality and safety of vaccines manufactured in China, as well as encouraging the public to stick to the vaccination program, which is the most efficient way to prevent infectious diseases.

The notices said no vaccine is entirely risk free and adverse reactions, which are usually mild and temporary, are common, though with a low rate of occurrence.

According to the Shanxi vaccination monitoring networks, about 10 million Shanxi residents receive vaccinations every year. There were 238 suspected adverse reactions reported from 2008 to 2009 and more than 20 people received compensation in recent years, Zhai Rufang, immunization division chief of the provincial CDC, was quoted by Xinhua News Agency as having said.

About the author


Jeffry John Aufderheide is the father of a child injured as a result of vaccination. As editor of the website he promotes well-educated pediatricians, informed consent, and full disclosure and accountability of adverse reactions to vaccines.